Top 12 Imperfect Foods Competitors & Alternatives

Imperfect Foods, headquartered in San Francisco, California, is a grocery delivery service that focuses on food that can’t be sold in supermarkets and other stores.

The company is able to deliver groceries right to your door at up to 30 percent off the supermarket store price. Apart from fruits and vegetables, customers can also order pre-packaged snacks, meat, and more.

It is able to do that because it focuses on sourcing imperfect products, namely the ones that have blemishes, bruises, scratches, scars, or any other type of damage. These products are oftentimes excluded from being sold at grocers and are thus thrown away.

Nevertheless, Imperfect Food’s products are perfectly edible. In fact, its products are often sourced from the same farmers and producers that supply other supermarket chains such as ALDI, Walmart, or Whole Foods.

On top of that, Imperfect Foods also helps combat food loss, which ranges between 30 to 40 percent of all food supply according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). ReFED, furthermore, estimates that 130 billion meals worth of food goes to waste – every year.

Imperfect Foods was founded in 2015 by Ben Simon, Benjamin Chesler, and Ron Clark. It has raised $229.1 million in funding according to Crunchbase. Since its inception, it helped to save 145 million lbs of food.

The methodology with which the competitors of Imperfect Foods are ranked is based on publicly available data. Since Imperfect Foods as well as many of its competitors remain in private ownership, data on revenue is sometimes only scarcely available.

We, therefore, rank the competition based on three key factors, namely how many people they employ, how much money they have raised, as well as the social impact they have had. That impact can be expressed through a variety of data points such as kilos/pounds of saved food, CO2 or water conserved, or people fed. Every company chooses to disclose different metrics to the public (and some, unfortunately, none).

Additionally, this analysis only takes U.S.-based grocery delivery services that focus on delivering fresh produce into account. The honorable mentions section, therefore, lists a few additional companies that operate in a slightly different space or tackle other markets.

This analysis should not be taken as a recommendation to make a particular purchase. It is merely a summary of all the competition that Imperfect Foods faces as of today.

So, without further ado, let’s take a closer look at the top 12 competitors of Imperfect Foods.

1. Misfits Market

Headquarters: Pennsauken, New Jersey, United States

Founder(s): Abhi Ramesh

Year Founded: 2018

Misfits Market, in all likeliness, is the strongest competitor that Imperfect Foods faces as of the time of writing.

It also focuses on saving ‘ugly’ produce from being thrown away and consequently sells it at a discount of up to 40 percent.

Misfits Market delivers across almost every state in the U.S. while the company itself decides what it puts into the boxes it delivers.

Investors certainly like what Misfits had been doing so far. They have poured a total of $526.5 million into the business, which now employs 250 people.

To date, the company has rescued 228 million pounds of food from being thrown away. 128 million lbs have been saved from waste in 2021 alone.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn, Misfits Market

2. Hungry Harvest

Headquarters: Baltimore, Maryland, United States

Founder(s): Evan Lutz, John Zamora

Year Founded: 2014

Hungry Harvest is another well-funded startup that focuses on ugly produce that it delivers to around a dozen states including Maryland, Florida, and more.

The founders raised awareness for the business by appearing two times on Shark Tank, which allowed them to raise the initial funding for their idea.

Since its inception in 2014, the company has been responsible for saving 27 million pounds of produce. It, furthermore, donated over 1.7 million pounds to people in need. Investors have rewarded the 65-people-strong company with close to $21 million in funding thus far.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn, Hungry Harvest

3. GrubMarket

Headquarters: San Francisco, California, United States

Founder(s): Mike Xu

Year Founded: 2014

GrubMarket directly connects farmers with customers via its proprietary platform across more than a dozen states.

On top of that, the company also sells its produce to other businesses at wholesale prices. It even offers a cloud-based software offering called WholesaleWare, which entails inventory management, eCommerce integrations, and more.

For its consumer-facing product, the company sells fruits, vegetables, and dairy products at up to 50 percent off. Customers can then have those products delivered straight to their homes.

The company has raised more than $382 million in funding while being valued at $1.2 billion. Moreover, it employs close to 100 people.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn

4. Perfectly Imperfect Produce

Headquarters: Willoughby Hills, Ohio, United States

Founder(s): Ashley Weingart

Year Founded: 2016

Founder Ashley Weingart was brought into her family’s business as a Director of Communications & Community Outreach. To combat the food waste she was observing, she launched Perfectly Imperfect as a program of Forest City Weingart Produce soon after.

The delivery service sources the imperfect produce from local farms and wholesalers. What differentiates Perfectly Imperfect from other services is its social mission. For every box purchased, it donates produce to people in need.

Right now, Perfectly Imperfect Produce only delivers in the state of Ohio. However, the company stated that it plans to soon expand into other states.

No outside funding has been raised to date. Perfectly Imperfect Produce has saved over one million pounds of food to date. Moreover, the company fed more than 100,000 people in need.

Sources: Perfectly Imperfect Produce

5. FreshDirect

Headquarters: New York City, United States

Founder(s): David McInerney, Jason Ackerman, Joe Fedele

Year Founded: 1998

FreshDirect delivers a variety of grocery products. This not only includes fresh produce but many other items such as frozen meats, bakeries, pre-cooked meals, and even alcoholic beverages.

The company employs a dedicated Food Safety and Quality Assurance department to guarantee the items it sells in its facility are safe to consume.

Customers simply select the products they want to be delivered, which are then prepared in FreshDirect’s local facilities and delivered using the firm’s refrigerated trucks and at the most suitable time.

Moreover, FreshDirect offers different memberships which customers can opt into to receive unlimited free delivery, exclusive promotions, and other freebies.

However, the company only delivers products in a few selected states such as New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and Washington.

In November 2020, FreshDirect was acquired by Holland-based supermarket chain Ahold Delhaize. The company has raised $280 million throughout its existence and employs over 1,000 people. The company fulfills 100,000 orders in the New York City area alone.

Sources: Business Insider,Crunchbase, LinkedIn

6. Farmbox Direct

Headquarters: New York City, United States

Founder(s): Ashley Tyrner

Year Founded: 2014

Once a week, Farmbox Direct delivers you a box full of fresh produce sourced by local farmers and businesses right to your doorstep.

You have the option to see what’s being harvested locally in order to choose your fruit and vegetable preferences. You can also substitute up to 5 items that may not be appealing to you. Customers can, furthermore, choose between having all-organic or conventional produce.

Since Farmbox Direct works together with FedEx for delivery, it is able to serve customers across the entire United States.

In 2020, the executive team has expanded the company into medicine by launching a pharmacy delivery service called FarmboxRX.

Its founder has yet to raise outside funding from institutional investors. As a result of the lack of capital, it currently only employs about 25 people. Unfortunately, Farmbox Direct does not disclose any data pertaining to the impact it had or the amount of food it has delivered thus far.

Sources: LinkedIn, Pitchbook

7. Farm to People

Headquarters: New York City, United States

Founder(s): Michael Robinov, David Robinov, Anina von Haeften  

Year Founded: 2013

Farm to People, as the name suggests, works together with local farms to provide customers with subscription boxes as well as individual groceries.

The company solely delivers within the New York area, namely Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Jersey City, and Hoboken.

Farmers who work together with the platform receive $0.50 for every $1 sold on average via the website. For comparison, farmers only get around $0.13 out of every dollar when selling to traditional retailers.

The company, which hasn’t taken on any funding and likely remains local for the time being, serves over 4,000 customers.

Sources: Crunchbase, Farm to People

8. Farm Fresh To You

Headquarters: Capay, California, United States

Founder(s): Kathleen Barsotti, Martin Barnes

Year Founded: 1976

Farm Fresh To You is a subscription box that solely delivers organic fruits and vegetables fresh. The service differentiates itself from other offerings by growing the produce itself.

In fact, the fruits and vegetables come from a farm that was started in the mid-1970s by graduate students Kathleen Barsotti and Martin Barnes. Their respective children have continued the family business and brought it into the 21st century.

Due to their roots, the company remains a small-scale operation and thus only serves customers in the state of California. However, their parent organization, Full Circle Farms, services other west coast cities such as Portland, Seattle, Spokane, Seattle.

The delivery service has not taken on any outside capital. Despite the lack of outside capital, it has managed to grow to around 240 employees. In recent times, the company has donated over 100,000 lbs of organic produce to local food banks.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn, Farm Fresh To You

9. Talley Farms Fresh Harvest

Headquarters: Arroyo Grande, California, United States

Founder(s): Oliver Talley

Year Founded: 1948

Another family-run business that turned its farm into a produce box is Talley Farms. Produce is directly delivered from its farm or can be picked up there as well.

The produce can be picked up throughout 70 convenient locations in San Luis Obispo and Northern Santa Barbara. Boxes come in two different sizes, namely Original and Junior.

No outside funding has been raised to date. Around 50 people are employed by Talley Farms, which also entails workers who don’t focus on the produce box.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn

10. The Chef’s Garden

Headquarters: Huron, Ohio, United States

Founder(s): unknown

Year Founded: 1984

Chef’s Garden is one of the largest producers of organic vegetables in America. With 600+ varieties of fruits and vegetables, their goal is to provide restaurants and the world’s top chefs with produce.

Consequently, the company also offers home delivery for consumers. Its most popular offering is its Best of the Season Box, which includes a variety of fruits and vegetables.

Chef’s Garden has not taken on any funding. Nevertheless, it has managed to grow to close to 100 employees.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn  

11. The FruitGuys

Headquarters: San Francisco, California, United States

Founder(s): Chris Mittelstaedt

Year Founded: 1998

Lastly, Misfit Markets faces competition from The FruitGuys, which as the name suggests, focuses on selling fruits.

However, its boxes also include other products such as vegetables as well as healthy snacks. The company mainly delivers across the San Francisco area.

More than 100 people are now employed by The FruitGuys. The company commits to donating 20 percent of its annual profits to fight hunger. As a result, it has donated over 18 million servings to date.

Sources: The FruitGuys

12. Full Harvest

Headquarters: San Francisco, California, United States

Founder(s): Christine Moseley

Year Founded: 2015

Full Harvest may not be going after the same type of customer that Imperfect Foods but I thought it was nevertheless worth a mention.

The company has created an online marketplace for business-to-business (B2B) customers, allowing them to purchase fresh produce in bulk and at wholesale prices.

It provides customers with a dedicated dashboard and account manager. The biggest advantage is that customers don’t need to negotiate rates any longer and can conduct the whole purchasing process within one platform.

Investors have rewarded Full Harvest, which employs around 50 people, with $34.5 million in funding. Unfortunately, it currently does not disclose how much food it helped to save.

Sources: Crunchbase, LinkedIn

Honorable Mentions

The above-mentioned companies are certainly not the only competition that Imperfect Foods currently faces.

Other, more established chains that Amazon Fresh or Whole Foods (which is also owned by Amazon) are certainly targeting the same type of health-conscious customers.

Moreover, Imperfect Foods competes against online delivery services such as Instacart, which in turn work together with other supermarket chains to serve their customers.

There are also examples of marketplaces gunning for Imperfect Foods’ supremacy. CropSwap, for example, offers a consumer-facing app where customers can order produce from local farms.

Nevertheless, establishing an online grocery delivery service remains a financially and logistically complex endeavor. London-based Farmdrop, which offered a similar service to customers in the U.K., had to close down in December 2021 despite over $40 million in funding.

Conclusion

Imperfect Foods remains one of the leading companies in the space that it operates in, that is delivering ‘ugly’ produce to customers.

However, competitors such as Misfits Market, GrubMarket, or Hungry Harvest have raised significant rounds of investment to dethrone the company. Misfits Market, in particular, is currently the most-hyped company in the space.

On top of that, there are a plethora of local operators that have originated out of farms, which produce their own fruits and vegetables.

Lastly, Imperfect Foods may eventually decide to expand into the lucrative B2B vertical to compete against businesses such as Full Harvest (which, in turn, could also create a consumer-facing segment).

Hi folks, Viktor checking in! Years of experience in various tech-related roles have led me to start this blog, which I hope provides you with as much enjoyment to read as I have writing the content.